Free Consultations & We're Available 24/7
WE'RE A BOUTIQUE LAW FIRM.
TRUST 50 YEARS OF EXPERIENCE.
WE SERVICE CLIENTS NATIONWIDE.
So your probably getting sued for something you didn’t even know was a problem, or maybe your landlord’s claiming damages that never happened, or worse – someone’s saying you injured them when they actually tripped over there own feet. Maybe your facing a breach of contract claim for millions. Maybe someone’s accusing you of property damage that was already there. Or maybe your being dragged into court by someone who just wants to squeeze money out of you. Look, we get it. Your ABSOLUTELY PANICKED. And you should be! Because civil lawsuits in NYC can destroy your finances with judgments that follow you forever according to NYC Civil Court statistics!
Let me break this down because alot of people don’t understand the massive difference. Criminal cases are when the government prosecutes you for breaking laws – theft, assault, drugs, whatever. You could go to jail. Civil litigation is completely different – it’s private parties suing each other for money or specific actions. Nobody’s going to prison in civil court, but you could lose everything you own.
In criminal court, they need proof beyond a reasonable doubt – like 95% sure your guilty. In civil court? They only need preponderance of evidence – basically 51% sure your liable. That’s it! Just slightly more likely than not and BAM – you lose. The burden is so much lower it’s scary.
Criminal defendants get public defenders if they can’t afford lawyers. Civil defendants? Your on your own. Can’t afford an attorney? Too bad. You’ll be representing yourself against experienced lawyers who know every trick in the book. And here’s the kicker – in civil court, staying silent can actually hurt you. Unlike criminal cases where you have the right to remain silent, judges and juries in civil cases can draw negative inferences if you don’t testify or answer discovery.
The stakes are different but equally devastating. Criminal conviction means jail and a record. Civil judgment means wage garnishment, asset seizure, liens on your property, destroyed credit. We’ve seen people lose there homes, retirement savings, everything because they didn’t take civil litigation seriously. And unlike criminal charges that might get dismissed or plea bargained down, civil plaintiffs often push cases all the way to trial because there hoping for a big payday.
This is CRITICAL and most people screw it up immediately! In New York, you typically have just 20 to 30 days to respond after being served, depending on how service happened. Twenty days if your personally served in New York. Thirty days if served by other methods or out of state. Miss that deadline? You’ve basically admitted everything and lost by default!
The clock starts ticking the second your served, not when you actually read the papers. Got served on Friday afternoon? Too bad, the clock is running through the weekend. On vacation when papers arrive? Doesn’t matter. Having a personal crisis? The court doesn’t care. Those 20-30 days fly by faster than you think, especialy when your scrambling to find a lawyer, understand what’s happening, and figure out how to pay for defense.
And here’s what nobody tells you – your response has to be legally sufficient according to CPLR Article 30. You can’t just write a letter saying “this is BS.” You need proper legal formatting, specific defenses, affirmative defenses, counterclaims if applicable. One technical mistake and the plaintiff can move to strike your answer, putting you back in default territory.
We see it constantly – people think they have time to “figure things out” or “see if it’s serious.” By the time they realize they need help, there already in default or about to be. Courts are not sympathetic to “I didn’t know” or “I was confused” or “I was trying to find a lawyer.” Default judgments get entered automatically and reversing them is expensive and difficult. Sometimes impossible.
The damages in civil litigation can be absolutely INSANE and most defendants have no idea what there facing. Compensatory damages cover actual losses – medical bills, property damage, lost wages. Sounds reasonable until you realize “lost wages” can include decades of future earnings. We’ve seen slip-and-fall cases turn into multi-million dollar claims because of alleged future medical needs and lost earning capacity.
Then there’s consequential damages – the ripple effects of whatever allegedly happened. Lost business opportunities, damaged reputation, emotional distress, loss of consortium. These are often way bigger than direct damages. Someone claims your negligence caused them to miss a business deal? Now there suing for millions in lost profits from a deal that might never have happened anyway.
Punitive damages are the really scary ones. If they can show you acted with malice, gross negligence, or reckless disregard, courts can award damages just to punish you. In New York, punitive damages aren’t capped for most civil cases. We’ve seen cases where actual damages were $50,000 but punitive damages were $500,000. Ten times the actual harm just to “send a message.”
Don’t forget about attorneys’ fees and costs. If there’s a contract with a fee-shifting provision or a statute that allows fee recovery, you could be on the hook for the other side’s legal bills. There $500/hour attorney working for two years? That’s potentially hundreds of thousands in fees alone. Plus expert witnesses, depositions, court costs. Even winning doesn’t mean you won’t pay.
Absolutely, and sometimes it’s your best defense strategy! Counterclaims can completely change case dynamics. That contractor suing you for non-payment? Maybe they did substandard work that damaged your property. That business partner claiming breach of contract? Perhaps they were stealing from the company. Counterclaims put plaintiffs on defense and give you leverage for settlement.
But here’s the catch – you MUST assert counterclaims in your answer or within the time limits set by CPLR Rule 3019. Miss the deadline and you might be barred from ever bringing those claims. Compulsory counterclaims arising from the same transaction must be brought or there waived forever. It’s use it or lose it.
Counterclaims need to be legitimate though. Filing frivolous counterclaims just to harass the plaintiff can result in sanctions under Rule 130-1.1. Courts here don’t tolerate games. We’ve seen defendants hit with thousands in sanctions for asserting baseless counterclaims. Plus, weak counterclaims can make you look desperate and hurt your credibility on defense.
The strategic value of counterclaims goes beyond just recovering damages. They complicate the plaintiff’s case, increase there legal costs, extend discovery into areas they might not want explored. A strong counterclaim can flip settlement dynamics completely. Suddenly the plaintiff who wanted $100,000 is worried about paying you $200,000. That’s when real settlement discussions begin.
Discovery is where civil litigation gets really expensive and invasive. Both sides get to demand documents, ask written questions (interrogatories), and take depositions. In New York, discovery is broader than most people imagine – basically anything that might lead to admissible evidence is fair game according to CPLR Article 31.
Document requests are nightmares. They’ll demand every email, text, financial record, photo, social media post related to the case. And “related” gets interpreted broadly. Slip and fall case? They want five years of your medical records. Contract dispute? Every communication with every business associate. The volume is overwhelming and production costs are insane – especially e-discovery with emails and electronic documents.
Depositions are even worse. You’ll be questioned under oath for up to seven hours by hostile attorneys trying to trap you. Every word is recorded by a court reporter. Say something wrong? It’ll be Exhibit A at trial. Forget something? They’ll claim your lying. Get emotional? They’ll argue your not credible. And you can’t refuse to answer except for narrow privilege claims.
Discovery compliance is mandatory with strict deadlines. Miss a deadline? Courts can preclude evidence, strike pleadings, or even enter default judgment as sanctions under CPLR 3126. We’ve seen cases lost purely because of discovery violations. And the costs are staggering – large cases can involve reviewing millions of documents, dozens of depositions, multiple expert witnesses. It’s not unusual for discovery to cost more than the amount in dispute.
Let’s be brutally honest – defending civil litigation in NYC is expensive as hell. Even “simple” cases rarely stay under $50,000 in legal fees. Complex litigation? Your looking at $200,000 to over $1 million easily. And that’s just attorney fees – not including experts, court reporters, document management, travel for depositions.
Most NYC litigation attorneys charge $400-$800 per hour for partners, $250-$500 for associates. Every email they read, every phone call, every court appearance – it all adds up fast. A single motion might take 40-60 hours to brief and argue. That’s $20,000 right there. Discovery disputes requiring court intervention? Add another $10,000-$15,000 per dispute.
Expert witnesses are budget killers too. Need a medical expert for a personal injury case? $500-$1,500 per hour plus review time, deposition time, trial time. Engineering expert for a construction defect case? Same rates or higher. Financial experts for business disputes? Don’t even ask. One case might need multiple experts, each costing tens of thousands.
Then there’s the hidden costs that nobody mentions. Lost productivity while your dealing with the lawsuit. Stress-related health issues. Damaged business relationships. Reputational harm that affects future opportunities. The emotional toll on family. These indirect costs often exceed the direct legal fees. We’ve seen successful businesses destroyed not by losing at trial but by the cost and distraction of defending litigation.
Statutes of limitations are your best friend as a defendant – if the plaintiff waited too long, case dismissed! But these deadlines are complicated and constantly changing. Personal injury claims generally have three years from the date of injury under CPLR 214. But there are tons of exceptions and special rules.
Breach of written contract? Six years. Oral contract? Three years. But when does the clock start? Date of breach? Date of discovery? Date damages occurred? It depends on the specific situation. Property damage is generally three years but if it involves latent defects, the discovery rule might extend it. Fraud claims have six years OR two years from discovery, whichever is longer.
Professional malpractice is really tricky. Legal malpractice is three years but continuous representation can toll it. Medical malpractice is two and a half years but foreign object cases have different rules. Accounting malpractice might be three or six years depending on the specific claim. And these are just the general rules – there are literally hundreds of exceptions.
Some claims have incredibly short deadlines that people miss constantly. Claims against municipalities require notice within 90 days and suit within one year and 90 days. Claims against certain public authorities have even shorter deadlines. Federal claims mixed with state claims? Different limitation periods for each. The interplay between statutes is so complex even experienced attorneys sometimes miss deadlines.
This is THE question keeping you up at night, and there’s no easy answer. Settlement means certainty – you know exactly what your paying and when it’s over. Trial means risk – you could win everything or lose catastrophically. Most civil cases (over 95%) settle before trial for good reasons.
Fighting costs are astronomical. Even if you win at trial, your out hundreds of thousands in legal fees unless you have fee-shifting provisions or claims. Appeals add years and more costs. During that whole time, your life is on hold. Every business decision, major purchase, or life change is complicated by pending litigation.
But settling when your innocent feels like extortion – and sometimes it basically is. Plaintiffs know defense costs and often demand settlements just below what fighting would cost. Pay $75,000 to settle or $100,000 to win at trial? Economically, settlement makes sense even though your right. It’s legalized shakedowns and it happens every day in NYC courts.
The decision depends on case strength, financial resources, risk tolerance, and life priorities. Strong defenses with documented evidence? Maybe fight. Weak case with sympathetic plaintiff? Consider settling. Can you afford years of litigation? Do you have the emotional stamina? What’s the impact on your business or family? Sometimes the best victory is ending the nightmare quickly, even if it costs money you shouldn’t have to pay.
Losing at trial is just the beginning of your nightmare, not the end. The judgment becomes a lien on all your real property in that county immediately. Own a house? Now there’s a judgment lien on it. The judgment creditor can force a sheriff’s sale to satisfy the debt. Your home could be auctioned off for pennies on the dollar.
Wage garnishment kicks in fast. In New York, they can take 10% of your gross income or 25% of disposable income, whichever is less. But “disposable” doesn’t mean what you think – it’s after taxes, not after your actual expenses. Making $100,000 a year? They’re taking $10,000 annually until the judgment plus interest is satisfied.
Bank accounts get frozen and seized through restraining notices under CPLR 5222. One day your accounts have money, next day they’re empty. They can grab checking, savings, investment accounts. Even joint accounts if your name is on them. We’ve seen people unable to pay rent or buy food because all there accounts were suddenly frozen.
The judgment lasts 20 years in New York and accrues interest at 9% annually! That $100,000 judgment becomes $200,000 in eight years with interest. And they can renew it for another 20 years. Bankruptcy might not even help – some judgments for intentional torts or fraud survive bankruptcy. Your basically financially enslaved until its paid or you die.
You have the right to represent yourself, but it’s like performing your own surgery – technically possible but probably catastrophic. NYC courts have pro se assistance programs and Help Centers, but they can only provide general information, not legal advice specific to your case.
The procedural requirements alone are overwhelming. Every filing needs proper formatting, service requirements, notarization, filing fees. Miss one technical requirement? Your papers get rejected. Use the wrong form? Start over. Serve improperly? Everything you did is void. Courts don’t cut pro se defendants any slack on procedural rules.
Substantive law is even worse. You need to know applicable statutes, case law, burdens of proof, evidentiary rules. The plaintiff’s attorney will object to everything you try to introduce at trial. Don’t know how to lay foundation for evidence? It’s excluded. Can’t properly authenticate documents? They’re out. Don’t understand hearsay rules? Your main defense might be inadmissible.
Going pro se against experienced attorneys is David vs Goliath except Goliath knows all the rules and you don’t even have a sling. We’ve watched pro se defendants with good defenses lose because they couldn’t navigate procedures. They had the evidence but couldn’t get it admitted. They had valid arguments but couldn’t articulate them legally. The justice system isn’t designed for self-representation, especially in complex civil litigation.
Look, we’re not gonna sugarcoat this – civil litigation defense is war and you need warriors who know the battlefield. We’ve been defending New York clients for years against every type of civil claim imaginable. Personal injury shakedowns, business disputes that turn nuclear, landlord-tenant battles, construction defect claims, professional liability allegations. We’ve seen it all and won cases everyone said were unwinnable.
We know NYC courts inside and out – which judges rush to trial, which ones encourage settlement, which ones are plaintiff-friendly. We know opposing counsel’s tactics before they use them. That ambulance chaser threatening millions? We know there actual settlement range. That white-shoe firm acting invincible? We know there pressure points.
Our approach is different because we treat your case like our own money is at stake. We don’t run up bills with unnecessary motions or endless document review. We identify the key issues that will actually determine outcomes and focus resources there. If settlement makes sense, we’ll tell you straight up. If fighting is smarter, we’ll go to war. No BS, no games, just honest assessment and aggressive representation.
Most importantly, we understand that your life is disrupted, your stressed out, and your scared about losing everything. We answer calls, respond to emails quickly, explain what’s happening in plain English. We handle the legal warfare so you can focus on your life and business. Because at the end of the day, our job isn’t just to win your case – it’s to get you through this nightmare with minimal damage to your life.
Call us RIGHT NOW at 212-300-5196
Every day you wait, the case builds against you!
Available 24/7 because lawsuits don’t follow business hours!
Don’t let them destroy your life with a civil lawsuit! The plaintiff has probably been planning this for months with there attorney while your just finding out. They have a head start and every day you delay gives them more advantage. Evidence disappears, witnesses forget, documents get lost. The sooner we start building your defense, the better chance we have of protecting everything you’ve worked for. Call immediately – your financial future depends on it!
This is attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee similar outcomes. Every case is unique. The information provided here is general and not specific legal advice for your situation. But one thing’s universal – delay in civil litigation always favors the plaintiff.
Very diligent, organized associates; got my case dismissed. Hard working attorneys who can put up with your anxiousness. I was accused of robbing a gemstone dealer. Definitely A law group that lays out all possible options and best alternative routes. Recommended for sure.
- ROBIN, GUN CHARGES ROBIN
NJ CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEYS