Free Consultations & We're Available 24/7
WE'RE A BOUTIQUE LAW FIRM.
TRUST 50 YEARS OF EXPERIENCE.
WE SERVICE CLIENTS NATIONWIDE.
So your probably trying to figure out if contempt means a few days in jail or if we’re talking about serious time, or maybe your lawyer mentioned “indefinite detention” and your mind is racing about what that actually means, or worse – someone you know has been in contempt detention for months already and your wondering when they’ll get out. Maybe you think there must be a maximum sentence like other crimes. Maybe your hoping it’s just until you pay a fine or something. Or maybe you’ve heard horror stories about people jailed for years and your praying those are exaggerations. Look, we get it. Your desperately trying to understand how long this nightmare could last. But here’s the absolutely terrifying truth – you can be jailed for contempt of a grand jury subpoena for YEARS or even DECADES, with no maximum limit in some cases according to Federal Judicial Center records!
For civil contempt, there is literally NO maximum time limit. You can be jailed indefinitely until you comply with the grand jury subpoena or until the grand jury’s term expires. We’re not talking about days or weeks here – people have spent YEARS in jail for refusing to testify or produce documents. The longest recorded cases are absolutely mind-blowing.
The typical federal grand jury sits for 18 months, with possible 6-month extensions. So at minimum, you could be jailed for up to 2 years just for one grand jury term. But here’s the nightmare – when that grand jury expires, prosecutors can convene a NEW grand jury investigating the same matter and subpoena you again. Refuse again? Another 18-24 months in jail.
This cycle can repeat indefinitely. Susan McDougal served 18 months. Chelsea Manning did 62 days, got released when that grand jury ended, then got immediately re-subpoenaed and jailed for another 10 months. Some people have been through multiple cycles, spending 3-4 years total in contempt detention across different grand jury terms.
The record holders are shocking. Dr. Stephen Chin spent nearly 3 years in federal detention for contempt. Martin Armstrong holds the Western world record at 7 YEARS in contempt detention for refusing to turn over assets. H. Beatty Chadwick spent 14 YEARS in jail for contempt in a civil case. These aren’t maximum sentences – these are real people who spent there lives in cages for refusing to comply.
Criminal contempt is separate punishment that gets added ON TOP of civil contempt detention. While your sitting in jail for civil contempt, prosecutors file criminal charges for your defiance. Get convicted? Now you owe additional time that must be served even if you eventually comply with the subpoena.
Criminal contempt sentences vary wildly based on the judge and circumstances. The statutory maximum is usually 6 months for “simple” contempt, but aggravated contempt or contempt involving obstruction of justice can result in years. We’ve seen criminal contempt sentences of 2-3 years for particularly defiant individuals.
The sentences stack. If you get 18 months civil contempt plus 2 years criminal contempt, your serving 3.5 years total. And remember – the criminal time can’t be avoided by eventually complying. Once convicted, you serve every day of that sentence regardless of later cooperation.
Certain factors can extend contempt detention far beyond normal limits. If the grand jury is investigating terrorism, national security, or organized crime, judges show zero leniency. They’ll keep you jailed for the entire grand jury term and eagerly approve extensions. National security cases have seen people jailed for 3+ years.
If your contempt is seen as protecting other criminals, judges impose maximum detention. They view you as an accomplice enabling ongoing crimes. Every day you refuse to testify is another day criminals avoid justice. Judges in these cases often publicly state they’ll keep you jailed as long as legally possible.
International investigations extend timelines dramatically. Multiple countries might be investigating simultaneously, with different grand juries in different jurisdictions. You could face contempt in federal court, then state court, then foreign proceedings. The detention periods stack up across jurisdictions.
Mental health claims rarely reduce detention. Judges order psychological evaluations to determine if you’re truly unable to comply versus choosing not to. Unless your literally incompetent, mental health issues don’t excuse non-compliance. People with severe depression and PTSD still serve years in contempt detention.
Long-term contempt detention is psychological torture. Your typically held in administrative segregation or SHU (Special Housing Unit) – basically solitary confinement. Twenty-three hours locked in a small cell. One hour for shower and “recreation” in a slightly larger cage. No human contact except guards through food slots.
After just 15 days, the UN considers solitary confinement to be torture. People in contempt detention spend MONTHS or YEARS in these conditions. Studies show permanent psychological damage occurs after just weeks. Hallucinations, paranoia, severe depression, suicide attempts – all common in long-term contempt detention.
The uncertainty is devastating. Regular prisoners know there release date. Contempt detainees don’t. Every day you wonder if today’s the day you’ll break. Every night you wonder how many more you can endure. The psychological pressure builds until people literally go insane from the combination of isolation and uncertainty.
Family relationships disintegrate during long-term detention. Marriages end. Children grow up without parents. Careers vanish. Homes get foreclosed. Everything you built over a lifetime disappears while your sitting in a cage. The life you return to (if you ever get out) is unrecognizable.
Federal judges have nearly unlimited discretion in contempt detention length. As long as they claim the detention has “coercive effect” – meaning it might eventually force compliance – they can keep you jailed indefinitely. Appellate courts rarely overturn these decisions.
Some judges are notorious for extreme contempt sentences. They view defiance as personal insults and respond vindictively. We’ve seen judges publicly state they’ll keep someone jailed “until they die” if necessary. These aren’t idle threats – they have the power and willingness to do it.
The judge’s mood and personal views matter enormously. Liberal judges might be more sympathetic to civil liberties arguments. Conservative judges often take harder lines on law and order. The judge assigned to your case could mean the difference between 30 days and 3 years in detention.
Attempts to switch judges or venues rarely succeed. The system protects judicial discretion in contempt matters. Once a judge decides your staying jailed, changing there mind is nearly impossible. Appeals take months or years while your rotting in detention.
Even when civil contempt detention ends, your not truly free. If you got released because the grand jury term expired (not because you complied), prosecutors can immediately re-subpoena you for a new grand jury. Refuse again? Back to jail for another 18-24 months.
Criminal contempt convictions mean supervised release after detention. Years of probation with strict conditions. Regular check-ins with federal officers. Travel restrictions. Continued cooperation requirements. Any violation sends you back to jail. The threat of re-incarceration hangs over you for years.
The psychological damage from long-term contempt detention is permanent. PTSD, severe anxiety, depression, paranoia – these don’t disappear when cell doors open. Many people require years of therapy. Some never fully recover. Suicide rates among former contempt detainees are astronomical.
Re-integration after years in detention is nearly impossible. The world moved on without you. Technology changed. Relationships ended. Professional skills atrophied. Your trying to rebuild a life from nothing while dealing with severe trauma. Most never fully recover there previous status.
The longest contempt detentions in U.S. history are absolutely shocking. H. Beatty Chadwick spent 14 YEARS in jail for civil contempt in a divorce case – the longest in U.S. history. He was 58 when jailed, 73 when released. His entire retirement spent in a cage for refusing to turn over money.
Martin Armstrong spent 7 years in contempt for refusing to turn over gold bars and computer code. He was held in the same facility as terrorists and murderers. His health deteriorated severely. He was finally released when a judge concluded further detention had lost its coercive effect.
Dr. Stephen Chin spent nearly 3 years jailed for refusing to testify about his employer’s activities. He maintained he knew nothing relevant but prosecutors didn’t believe him. Three years of his life gone because authorities thought he was hiding information.
These aren’t anomalies – they’re examples of what’s possible when judges decide to use maximum contempt powers. Any federal judge can keep you jailed for years if they believe your defiance threatens the justice system. The only limits are the judge’s conscience and the grand jury’s term.
The lack of maximum sentences for civil contempt is intentional. If people knew they’d only serve 30 days or 6 months maximum, many would choose jail over compliance. The indefinite nature is what makes it coercive. The uncertainty and potential for years of detention breaks most people’s will.
Courts have repeatedly upheld indefinite contempt detention as constitutional. As long as the detention maintains “coercive effect,” it can continue forever. Only when judges conclude you’ll NEVER comply – that detention has become purely punitive – must they release you. But that determination could take years.
International human rights organizations condemn America’s indefinite contempt detention as torture. No other Western democracy allows such extended detention without trial or conviction. But U.S. courts defend it as essential to the justice system’s functioning. Without indefinite detention, they argue, grand juries couldn’t function.
Call us RIGHT NOW at 212-300-5196
People spend YEARS in jail for contempt – don’t let it happen to you!
Available 24/7 before indefinite detention becomes your reality!
The terrifying reality is you could spend YEARS or even DECADES in jail for contempt of a grand jury subpoena! There’s no maximum sentence for civil contempt – people have served 14 YEARS. Add criminal contempt and the time extends further. This isn’t theoretical – it happens regularly to people who thought they could refuse to comply. Don’t gamble years of your life on principle or fear. Call us immediately – we’ll help you comply properly and avoid the nightmare of indefinite detention. Every day you wait increases the risk of spending YEARS behind bars!
This is attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee similar outcomes. Contempt detention lengths vary dramatically based on judges and circumstances.
Very diligent, organized associates; got my case dismissed. Hard working attorneys who can put up with your anxiousness. I was accused of robbing a gemstone dealer. Definitely A law group that lays out all possible options and best alternative routes. Recommended for sure.
- ROBIN, GUN CHARGES ROBIN
NJ CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEYS