Free Consultations & We're Available 24/7
WE'RE A BOUTIQUE LAW FIRM.
TRUST 50 YEARS OF EXPERIENCE.
WE SERVICE CLIENTS NATIONWIDE.
So your probably thinking you’ll get a chance to show the grand jury evidence proving your innocence, or maybe your planning to explain your side of the story with documents that clear everything up, or worse – you’ve gathered mountains of exculpatory evidence but just found out you can’t present any of it. Maybe you think fairness means both sides get to present evidence. Maybe your hoping your lawyer can at least submit documents on your behalf. Or maybe you believe the grand jury wants to hear your defense. Look, let me tell you something – your desperately trying to defend yourself in proceedings designed to exclude you entirely. But heres the OUTRAGEOUS truth – you have absolutely NO right to present ANY evidence to the grand jury in your defense, while prosecutors can present whatever they want without challenge according to federal rules that create completely one-sided proceedings!
Let me crush your hopes immediately – you CANNOT present evidence to the grand jury. Not documents, not witness testimony, not video recordings, not expert reports, not anything. The grand jury room is completely closed to defense evidence. Your shut out entirely from proceedings that might destroy your life.
Your expensive defense attorney with boxes of exculpatory documents? Can’t submit anything. Those witnesses ready to testify you were nowhere near the crime? Can’t bring them in. The video proving your innocence? Grand jury will never see it. The expert report destroying the prosecution’s theory? Might as well not exist.
This isn’t some oversight or procedural quirk – its deliberately designed to give prosecutors total control. Grand jury proceedings are NOT trials where both sides present evidence. There one-sided prosecutorial shows where only the government’s version gets heard. Your evidence, no matter how powerful, is completely excluded.
The fundamental unfairness is staggering. Prosecutors can present there case without any opposition, challenge, or balance. They show only incriminating evidence while your exculpatory evidence sits outside, legally banned from the room. Its like a trial where only the prosecution gets to speak – because that’s exactly what it is.
Here’s what makes it worse – in federal court, prosecutors have NO duty to present evidence favorable to you! They can have absolute proof of your innocence sitting in there files and choose not to show it to the grand jury. They can know witnesses who would exonerate you and never call them. They can possess documents clearing you and keep them hidden.
The Supreme Court ruled in United States v. Williams that prosecutors don’t have to present exculpatory evidence to grand juries. They can present a completely one-sided view, showing only evidence that makes you look guilty while concealing everything that proves innocence. How the hell is that justice?
Some states require prosecutors to present “substantial exculpatory evidence,” but federal prosecutors don’t. And even in states with this requirement, “substantial” is interpreted so narrowly that most helpful evidence doesn’t qualify. Prosecutors decide what’s “substantial,” and surprise – they rarely think defense evidence meets that standard.
DOJ policy says prosecutors should present evidence that “directly negates guilt” if there “personally aware” of it. But who enforces this policy? Nobody. Who knows if prosecutors follow it? Nobody. Who punishes violations? Nobody. Its meaningless words on paper while prosecutors do whatever they want in secret proceedings.
Sometimes prosecutors “invite” targets to testify before the grand jury. This sounds like your chance to present your defense, right? WRONG! This invitation is almost always a trap designed to lock you into testimony that becomes evidence against you.
First, you testify WITHOUT your lawyer present. Your alone facing experienced prosecutors in an intimidating setting. No one to object to improper questions. No one to protect you from traps. No one to advise you in real-time. Your completely vulnerable to prosecutorial manipulation.
Second, prosecutors control your testimony completely. They ask the questions they want, in the order they want, with the spin they want. You can’t just tell your story – you respond to there interrogation. They’ll interrupt favorable explanations, dwell on problematic areas, and twist your words.
Third, anything you say can and will be used against you. That innocent explanation? Prosecutors will find inconsistencies. That helpful context? They’ll claim it proves guilty knowledge. That emotional defense? They’ll say it shows consciousness of guilt. Your testimony becomes ammunition for prosecution, not exoneration.
Think you can at least submit documents proving innocence? Think again. You have no mechanism to provide documents to grand juries. You can’t mail them in. You can’t have them delivered. You can’t submit them through the court. The grand jury is completely insulated from defense evidence.
Your lawyer might try sending exculpatory documents to prosecutors, hoping they’ll present them. But prosecutors have no obligation to show them to grand jurors. They’ll review them, decide there “not relevant” or “not substantial,” and file them away while proceeding with indictment.
Even if you have iron-clad documentary proof of innocence – video showing you elsewhere, contracts proving legitimate business, emails demonstrating good faith – none of it reaches the grand jury unless prosecutors choose to present it. And why would they present evidence that undermines there case?
The documents that could save you sit in your lawyer’s office, powerless to help. Meanwhile, prosecutors present there selected documents, taken out of context, spun negatively, without any balancing evidence. The grand jury sees a carefully curated prosecutor exhibition, not the full documentary truth.
You might have ten witnesses ready to testify to your innocence, but they can’t appear before the grand jury unless prosecutors call them. And guess what? Prosecutors won’t call witnesses that help you. Why would they undermine there own case?
Even if prosecutors do call your witnesses (usually to trap them), the questioning is completely hostile. Prosecutors control examination without any friendly direct examination first. Your witnesses face aggressive interrogation designed to minimize helpful testimony and maximize problems.
Your character witnesses who would testify to your honesty? Not allowed. Expert witnesses who would destroy the prosecution’s theory? Banned. Fact witnesses who would provide exculpatory evidence? Excluded. The grand jury never hears from people who could balance the prosecutor’s narrative.
If your witnesses try to volunteer to testify, they’re turned away. There’s no mechanism for defense witnesses to appear voluntarily. The prosecutor is the sole gatekeeper of who testifies, ensuring only there narrative gets presented. Your witness list is worthless paper.
Your defense team might include skilled investigators who’ve uncovered evidence proving innocence. These investigators have interviewed witnesses, analyzed documents, reconstructed events. They have evidence that would change everything. But they can’t present any of it to the grand jury.
Private investigators, forensic experts, accident reconstructionists – all banned from grand jury proceedings. There findings, no matter how significant, never reach grand jurors. The extensive defense investigation that cost you thousands might as well not exist as far as the grand jury is concerned.
Meanwhile, prosecutors present there investigators freely. FBI agents, IRS analysts, DEA experts – all testify to there findings without challenge. The grand jury hears only government investigation results while defense investigation is excluded entirely. The information asymmetry is absolute.
Your investigator might have proof the government’s key witness is lying. Doesn’t matter – grand jury won’t hear it. Your expert might have evidence the government’s theory is scientifically impossible. Too bad – grand jury remains ignorant. The truth is actively excluded while lies go unchallenged.
You might think judges could order prosecutors to present defense evidence or allow defense participation. WRONG! Judges have no role in grand jury proceedings. There’s no judge present, no judicial supervision, no avenue for judicial intervention.
You can’t file motions asking judges to admit defense evidence to grand juries. You can’t request hearings on evidentiary fairness. You can’t appeal to judicial authority for basic fairness. Judges are completely excluded from grand jury proceedings, unable to help even if they wanted.
This absence of judicial oversight means prosecutors operate without any check on there power. They can exclude defense evidence without justification. They can present misleading evidence without consequence. They can manipulate proceedings without supervision. There’s no referee ensuring fair play.
The courthouse might be full of judges, but none can help you during grand jury proceedings. Your locked out of your own case with no judicial recourse. The prosecutors who want to destroy you have total control while judges stand aside, powerless to intervene.
Knowing you have powerful evidence of innocence that the grand jury will never see creates unique psychological torture. You watch prosecutors build there false narrative while truth sits excluded. You see your future being destroyed by lies while evidence of truth is legally banned.
Every day of proceedings, you know witnesses are testifying against you without anyone presenting your defense. Documents are being mischaracterized without correction. Evidence is being spun without balance. Your screaming the truth internally while forced into external silence.
Your lawyer has boxes of exculpatory evidence that might as well be empty. Your witnesses are ready to testify but might as well not exist. Your innocence is provable but unpresentable. The frustration of having answers that can’t be given is maddening.
Call us RIGHT NOW at 212-300-5196
You CAN’T present defense evidence – but we’ll find other ways to fight!
Available 24/7 to combat completely one-sided proceedings!
The bottom line is you have absolutely NO right to present ANY evidence to the grand jury in your defense – not documents, not witnesses, not testimony, NOTHING! Prosecutors have no obligation to present exculpatory evidence in federal court. Invitations to testify are usually traps. Your witnesses are banned unless prosecutors call them. Defense investigators and experts are completely excluded. Judges can’t help you. Your forced to watch prosecutors present a one-sided case while your defense evidence is legally prohibited. Call us IMMEDIATELY – while we can’t present evidence to grand juries, we’ll find other ways to fight these unfair proceedings!
This is attorney advertising. Prior results dont guarantee similar outcomes. Grand jury proceedings deliberately exclude defense participation.
Very diligent, organized associates; got my case dismissed. Hard working attorneys who can put up with your anxiousness. I was accused of robbing a gemstone dealer. Definitely A law group that lays out all possible options and best alternative routes. Recommended for sure.
- ROBIN, GUN CHARGES ROBIN
NJ CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEYS