SEC DEFENSE

SEC Settlement vs Going to Trial: What You Need to Know

April 1, 2026 2 minutes read By Todd Spodek, Esq.
FREE CASE EVALUATION
Spodek Law Group - NYC Criminal Defense Attorneys

Learn more about Spodek Law Group and how we can help with your case.

When facing investigation by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the prospect of going to trial can be daunting. SEC enforcement actions are high-stakes matters, and the consequences of an unfavorable outcome at trial can be severe. While the SEC routinely settles its enforcement cases, this does not mean that it will be willing to settle in your case.

The decision to settle or go to trial is a critical one, and it must be based on a clear and comprehensive understanding of the facts at hand and the potential consequences of both options.

1. Not All SEC Settlements Are Created Equal

Most SEC investigations are resolved by settlement. But this does not mean that all settlements are the same. While entering into a settlement may allow you to avoid the risks of going to trial, it will still involve a finding of liability for some type of securities law violation.

2. Having Leverage in Settlement Negotiations Is Key

The more leverage you have, the more negotiating power you will have — and the better your chances of securing a favorable outcome. Ideally, you will want to be able to show the SEC that it will not prevail at trial.

3. In Some Cases, Settling Offers a Win-Win Solution

If you made a mistake in the past but have since cleaned up your practices, then a settlement could allow you to avoid an enforcement action. The terms of the settlement will be critical.

4. In Some Cases, Going to Trial Might Be the Best Option

If settling is not viable — either because the SEC is unwilling to settle on acceptable terms or because you believe you can win at trial — then your only option may be to prepare for trial.

5. You Can Pursue Both Settlement and Trial Preparation Simultaneously

By doing so, you can put yourself in the best position to achieve a favorable outcome. Pursuing both simultaneously can also put pressure on the SEC to settle.

6. Consider the Full Range of Potential Outcomes

This includes not only the potential financial consequences, but also the potential reputational and operational consequences as well. A settlement could involve a significant financial penalty. A trial could result in a finding of liability with significant impact on your reputation.

7. Avoiding Liability Should Be Your Top Priority

Whether this means settling or going to trial, the objective should be to achieve a favorable outcome that allows you to move forward without the burden of liability. Work with experienced legal counsel to develop a comprehensive strategy tailored to your specific needs.

Legal Pulse: NJ Criminal Justice
44%
Bail Reform Impact

Reduction in pretrial jail population since NJ bail reform implementation.

Source: NJ Judiciary Annual Report
92%
Expungement Success

Approval rate for properly filed expungement petitions in NJ.

Source: NJ Courts Statistical Report

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Actually Stay Silent

Most people know they have the right to remain silent but still talk to police. Anything you say can and will be used against you. Politely decline to answer questions until your attorney is present.

Bail Conditions Are Enforceable

Violating bail conditions, even minor ones, can result in immediate re-arrest and make it much harder to obtain bail again. Follow every condition to the letter.

Proven Track Record

Recent Case Results

NO CHARGES FILED
SEC Investigation
SETTLEMENT REDUCED 80%
Securities Fraud
LICENSE PRESERVED
FINRA Action
CASE DISMISSED
Insider Trading Allegation

*Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

SEE ALL CASE RESULTS

What Our Clients Say

"Facing an SEC investigation was terrifying. The Spodek team negotiated a resolution that preserved my career and my reputation. Their knowledge of securities law is unmatched."
— David A., SEC Defense Client MORE REVIEWS
Todd Spodek — Lead Attorney

Lead Attorney & Founder

Todd Spodek

Featured on Netflix's "Inventing Anna," Todd Spodek brings decades of high-stakes criminal defense experience to every case.

NY Bar Admitted NJ Bar Admitted Federal Courts
Meet the Full Team

Need Help With Your Case?

Our experienced criminal defense attorneys are available 24/7 for a confidential consultation.

100% Confidential. Your information is protected.

Frequently Asked Questions

89%
SEC Case Resolution Rate
1,200+
Securities Cases
67%
Charges Reduced or Dismissed
$2.1B
Client Assets Protected

Why Clients Choose Spodek Law Group

45 seconds that explain our difference

Why Clients Choose Spodek Law Group

Get Advice From An Experienced Criminal Defense Lawyer

Schedule your free consultation today. Available 24/7.

Your information is 100% confidential and protected.

Tap to Call — (212) 300-5196