Free Consultations & We're Available 24/7
WE'RE A BOUTIQUE LAW FIRM.
TRUST 50 YEARS OF EXPERIENCE.
WE SERVICE CLIENTS NATIONWIDE.
So your probably confused about what this “immunity” thing means when prosecutors mention it regarding your grand jury testimony, or maybe they’ve offered you immunity and your wondering if its a trap, or worse – you think immunity means you can say whatever you want without consequences. Maybe you believe immunity protects you completely from prosecution. Maybe your hoping it means you don’t have to testify at all. Or maybe you think once you have immunity, your totally safe forever. Look, let me tell you something – your desperately trying to understand whether immunity is your salvation or your doom. But heres the CRUCIAL reality – immunity in grand jury proceedings means prosecutors can FORCE you to testify by removing your Fifth Amendment protection, and while it prevents them from using your words directly against you, it’s NOT the blanket protection you think according to federal immunity statutes that create more problems than they solve!
Let me shatter your illusions right now – immunity isn’t some gift prosecutors give you out of kindness. Its a WEAPON they use to force testimony from people who would otherwise invoke the Fifth Amendment. Once you have immunity, you lose your constitutional right to remain silent. Refuse to testify with immunity? Your going to jail for contempt immediately.
The whole point of immunity is to destroy your ability to stay quiet. Prosecutors don’t grant immunity to help you – they grant it to help themselves. They want your testimony to use against bigger targets, and immunity is how they force you to become there witness whether you want to or not.
Think of immunity as legal handcuffs that compel you to talk. Without it, you can invoke the Fifth Amendment and stay silent. With it, you MUST answer every question or face immediate imprisonment for contempt. Its not protection – its compulsion disguised as protection.
And heres the sick part – prosecutors decide who gets immunity based entirely on there strategic needs. Your not getting immunity because your innocent or deserve protection. Your getting it because forcing your testimony serves there purposes. Your a tool in there investigation, nothing more.
Federal prosecutors typically grant “use and derivative use immunity” under 18 U.S.C. § 6002, and its WAY weaker than it sounds. This type of immunity only prevents prosecutors from using your actual testimony or evidence derived DIRECTLY from it against you. But they can still prosecute you using independent evidence – and they will.
Use immunity means they can’t quote your grand jury testimony at your trial. They can’t use leads from your testimony to find evidence. But if they find evidence through completely independent means, your toast. And guess what? Prosecutors are experts at parallel construction – building cases with “independent” evidence that mysteriously appears after your testimony.
Example: You testify under immunity about a fraud scheme. Prosecutors can’t use your admission against you. But then they “independently” subpoena bank records, interview witnesses who “coincidentally” remember things, and build a case that doesn’t technically use your testimony. Your still getting prosecuted, just with different evidence.
Transactional immunity – which actually protects you from prosecution for crimes you testify about – is like a unicorn in federal court. It provides blanket protection for the entire “transaction” you discuss. If you get transactional immunity for testifying about a bank robbery, you can never be prosecuted for that robbery. Sounds great, right?
Too bad federal prosecutors HATE transactional immunity and almost never grant it. Why would they give up the right to prosecute you? They only offer it in extraordinary circumstances when your testimony is absolutely crucial and they have no other choice. We’re talking about testifying against cartel leaders or terrorism masterminds – and even then its rare.
State prosecutors might offer transactional immunity more often, but federal prosecutors? Forget about it. They’ll fight tooth and nail to give you only use immunity. They want to preserve every option to prosecute you later. Transactional immunity means letting you walk free, and that makes prosecutors physically ill.
If someone promises you transactional immunity, get it in writing, have your lawyer review every word, and still don’t trust it completely. Prosecutors are masters at drafting immunity agreements with loopholes. That “complete immunity” might only cover specific dates, specific crimes, or specific jurisdictions. One step outside those boundaries and your facing charges.
Think immunity means you can say whatever you want? WRONG! You can still be prosecuted for perjury if you lie. You can still be prosecuted for crimes you commit AFTER testifying. You can still be prosecuted by other jurisdictions. You can still face civil lawsuits. Immunity is narrow, specific, and full of exceptions.
Perjury is the big one. Immunity doesn’t give you license to lie. Every false statement under immunity is a separate federal felony punishable by 5 years in prison. Prosecutors LOVE charging immunized witnesses with perjury because its easy to prove and shows other witnesses the consequences of lying.
Future crimes are completely unprotected. If you testify about past drug dealing under immunity, then go deal drugs again tomorrow, your getting prosecuted for the new crimes. Immunity only covers what you testify about, not your future criminal career.
Other jurisdictions can still prosecute you. Federal immunity doesn’t bind state prosecutors. State immunity doesn’t bind federal prosecutors. Foreign governments don’t care about your U.S. immunity deal. You might be protected in one court while facing charges in another.
Once prosecutors grant you immunity, your trapped in a vicious cycle. You MUST testify or face contempt. But testifying might expose you to other dangers – retaliation from people you testify against, parallel prosecution through “independent” evidence, or perjury charges if you make any mistakes.
Contempt for refusing to testify with immunity is immediate and harsh. Judges have zero patience for immunized witnesses who won’t talk. Your jailed indefinitely – could be 18 months or longer – until you testify or the grand jury term expires. No bail, no home detention, just federal jail until you break.
But testifying creates other problems. Your testimony becomes public record eventually. People you testify against will know exactly what you said. If these are dangerous people, immunity doesn’t protect you from there retaliation. Prosecutors might promise protection, but witness protection is rare and life-destroying.
The stress is unbearable. Refuse to testify? Jail. Testify truthfully? Maybe retaliation. Make a mistake? Perjury charges. Try to minimize your involvement? More perjury charges. Theres no good option once immunity attaches. Your forced to choose between terrible alternatives.
The decision to grant immunity is entirely up to prosecutors – you can’t demand it, judges can’t force it, and your lawyer can’t negotiate it without prosecutor agreement. If prosecutors want your testimony badly enough, they’ll immunize you. If they’d rather prosecute you, they won’t. You have zero control.
Timing is completely in prosecutors’ hands. They might wait until the last minute to grant immunity, leaving you no time to prepare. Or they might grant it early to lock you into testimony before you fully understand the implications. The timing is always strategic and always benefits them, not you.
The scope of immunity is carefully limited. Prosecutors draft immunity orders as narrowly as possible. It might only cover certain topics, certain time periods, or certain crimes. Step outside those boundaries and your unprotected. Every word is crafted to give you minimum protection while extracting maximum testimony.
Revocation is possible if you violate terms. Most immunity agreements have conditions – truthful testimony, complete cooperation, no future crimes. Violate any condition and prosecutors can revoke immunity and use everything against you. Its like testifying without immunity but worse because you thought you were protected.
If your testimony involves international crimes, U.S. immunity means nothing abroad. Foreign prosecutors can still charge you. Foreign governments can seek extradition. Your U.S. immunity agreement is toilet paper in foreign courts.
International businesses face impossible situations. Testify under U.S. immunity about foreign corrupt practices? Foreign governments might prosecute you for admitting crimes in there jurisdiction. Refuse to testify? U.S. contempt charges. Your trapped between competing legal systems with no good options.
Even worse, some countries view immunized testimony as evidence of guilt. Your “protected” admission in the U.S. becomes a confession abroad. That immunity deal just created international criminal exposure you didn’t have before.
Call us RIGHT NOW at 212-300-5196
Immunity is NOT complete protection – you need expert help understanding the trap!
Available 24/7 to navigate the dangerous complexities of immunity agreements!
The bottom line is immunity in grand jury proceedings means prosecutors can FORCE you to testify by destroying your Fifth Amendment rights, and refusing means immediate jail for contempt! Use immunity only prevents them from using your actual words against you – they can still prosecute with “independent” evidence. Transactional immunity barely exists in federal court. You can still be charged with perjury, future crimes, and by other jurisdictions. Once immunity attaches, your trapped between contempt and testimony with no good options. Call us IMMEDIATELY if prosecutors are discussing immunity – we’ll help you understand the real implications and protect you from the countless traps immunity creates!
This is attorney advertising. Prior results dont guarantee similar outcomes. Immunity agreements require careful legal analysis.
Very diligent, organized associates; got my case dismissed. Hard working attorneys who can put up with your anxiousness. I was accused of robbing a gemstone dealer. Definitely A law group that lays out all possible options and best alternative routes. Recommended for sure.
- ROBIN, GUN CHARGES ROBIN
NJ CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEYS