Free Consultations & We're Available 24/7
WE'RE A BOUTIQUE LAW FIRM.
TRUST 50 YEARS OF EXPERIENCE.
WE SERVICE CLIENTS NATIONWIDE.
So your probably freaking out right now because your facing your first federal charge ever and you can’t stop thinking about one question – am I going to federal prison? No criminal history, never even got a speeding ticket, and now your caught up in the same federal system they use for mobsters and terrorists. Maybe the FBI raided your house at 6 AM. Maybe you got a target letter in the mail. Or maybe they just arrested you at work in front of everyone. Look, we get it. Your ABSOLUTELY TERRIFIED. And honestly? You should be! Because the feds don’t care that your a first-timer – they treat you like your John Gotti!
Let me tell you the truth nobody wants to say out loud – being a first-time offender helps, but it definately doesn’t save you. Want to know something that’ll make you sick? Nearly ONE IN THREE federal inmates had never been arrested before! Your clean record gives you some advantage at sentencing, sure, but it doesn’t answer what your really asking – am I walking out of that courtroom or going to prison? Here’s the harsh reality – federal prosecutors don’t waste there time on small cases. If your case went federal instead of staying in state court, that alone tells you the goverment thinks this is serious. Doesn’t matter if its your first offense or your hundredth. White-collar fraud with big losses? Your probably going to prison. Drug case with weight that triggers mandatory minimums? Prison. Any firearms involved? Prison. Violence? Definately prison. The thing that determines your fate isn’t your biography – its the offense level calculation. The federal sentencing guidelines basicaly turn you into a number by combining two things: what you alegedly did (offense level) and your criminal history (category). First-timers usually fall into Category I, which is the lowest. Great, right? Wrong! If your offense level is high enough, even Category I won’t save you from prison. Think about it – fraud scheme involving $2 million? Your looking at an offense level that means PRISON. Drug quantities that put you at level 26 or higher? PRISON. Did you try to cover things up during the investigation? That’s obstruction of justice and it drives your level up no matter how clean your record is. We’ve seen it happen alot – people who never had a parking ticket going to federal prison because there offense level was just too high to avoid it.
Okay this is where things get really interesting for first-timers. Starting November 1, 2023, something called Amendment 821 created this “zero-point offender” adjustment that could literally be the difference between prison and freedom. If you qualify – and that’s a big IF – you get a TWO-LEVEL REDUCTION in your offense level. Doesn’t sound like much? IT’S HUGE! To qualify for this reduction you need ALL of these: – Zero criminal history points (absolutley no prior convictions) – No violence or even threats of violence – No firearms anywhere in your case – Not terrorism, sex offenses, or hate crimes – Nobody died or got seriously hurt – Your not running some continuing criminal enterprise Let me explain why this matters so much. If your offense level is 13, that’s Zone C on the sentencing table – which means MANDATORY PRISON TIME. But with the two-level reduction? Now your at level 11, which is Zone B where the judge can give you probation with home confinement instead! According to the U.S. Sentencing Commission, over 7,000 people currently in federal prison qualify for this reduction retroactively. That’s how big a deal this is!
The Federal First Offenders Act (FFOA) is something completley different – and alot of people get confused about this. FFOA is ONLY for simple drug possession cases. Not distribution, not trafficking, not conspiracy – just straight possession for personal use. Here’s what you need to qualify for FFOA: – First-time drug possession charge only – No prior drug convictions at all (state or federal) – Simple possession – not intent to distribute – Never been in any other first offender program before If you qualify and complete the probation sucessfully, your charges get DISMISSED ENTIRELY. Like it never happened. No conviction on your record. But here’s the catch that nobody tells you – this only works for possession charges. If there charging you with anything more than simple possession (and they usually are), FFOA won’t help you at all. We’ve gotten dozens of clients into FFOA programs over the years, but timing is everything. You have to request it BEFORE sentencing and the prosecutor has to agree. Once the judge sentences you, its too late – the opportunity is gone forever. That’s why you need attorneys who know about FFOA from day one, not lawyers who find out about it after its too late!
Let’s say the worst happens and you do get sentenced to federal prison – your sentence doesn’t mean what you think it means. Especialy after the First Step Act changes. A ten-year sentence does NOT mean ten years locked up in a cell! Here’s how it really works: **Good Time Credits** – You automaticaly earn 54 days off per year just for not getting in trouble. That’s roughly 15% off your total sentence. So ten years becomes 8.5 years just with good time. First-timers almost always get maximum good time because they don’t have gang affiliations or prison politics to worry about. **First Step Act Credits** – This is where it gets really interesting. You can earn 10 to 15 days of credit for EVERY 30 DAYS you participate in approved programs. These don’t reduce your sentence – they reduce time in ACTUAL PRISON. You serve the rest in halfway houses or home confinement! Do the math with me – if your earning 12 days per month over five years, that’s 720 days. That’s TWO WHOLE YEARS you don’t spend in federal prison! Combined with good time, a ten-year sentence could mean only six years in actual prison, with the rest in a halfway house or at home with an ankle monitor. But there’s catches (there always is with the feds). You have to actively participate in programs, maintain perfect conduct, and be classified as low risk. First-timers usualy meet these requirements easier than repeat offenders though.
Can first-timers get probation? Yes, but it depends completley on where you fall on the sentencing table. The guidelines divide everything into four zones: **Zone A** – Offense levels 1-8 – Straight probation available **Zone B** – Offense levels 9-11 – Probation with home confinement **Zone C** – Offense levels 12-13 – Split sentence (some prison required) **Zone D** – Offense levels 14+ – Prison required, period This is why the zero-point offender reduction is SO CRITICAL! If your at level 13 (Zone C requiring prison) but qualify for the reduction, you drop to 11 (Zone B where probation is possible). That’s literally the difference between going to prison and watching Netflix at home with an ankle bracelet! We’ve seen this work countless times since November 2023. People who would have definately gone to prison under the old rules are getting probation with home confinement. But you need lawyers who understand these calculations and can argue for every single reduction possible. Most attorneys don’t even know about the zero-point adjustment yet!
Some things virtually guarantee your going to prison no matter how clean your record is: **Mandatory Minimum Sentences** – If your facing charges with mandatory minimums – certain drug weights, firearms offenses, child stuff – the judge has ZERO discretion. Five year mandatory means five years MINIMUM, period. Doesn’t matter if your Mother Teresa with no record. The judge literaly cannot go below the mandatory minimum. **Large Loss Amounts** – The DOJ won’t even prosecute fraud unless losses are over $250,000 usualy. At that level, your starting at offense level 19. Even with all possible reductions, your still in Zone D – mandatory prison. We’ve seen first-timers with million dollar frauds get 3-5 years even with zero criminal history. **Obstruction of Justice** – This is the killer for alot of first-timers. You panic, you lie to the FBI, you delete some emails, you tell a witness not to cooperate. Boom – obstruction enhancement. We’ve seen people turn probation-eligible cases into mandatory prison by trying to cover things up. NEVER LIE TO FEDERAL AGENTS! They already know the answer when they ask the question! **Going to Trial** – The “trial penalty” is real and its brutal. If you go to trial and lose, your sentence will be 60-70% higher on average than if you took a plea. Over 97% of federal defendants plead guilty because of this. Its not fair, but its reality. First-timers who think they can win at trial often get crushed with massive sentences when they lose.
Between your guilty plea (or conviction if you went to trial) and sentencing, a probation officer creates your Pre-Sentence Investigation Report (PSR). This document is MORE IMPORTANT than your actual trial! The PSR calculates your guideline range, investigates your background, and makes a recomendation to the judge. What you do during this period – usually 60-90 days – matters more than anything else for first-timers. The probation officer interviews you (with your lawyer present hopefully). What you say, how you act, whether you show genuine remorse – this isn’t just going through the motions. The officer’s recommendation carries HUGE weight with judges! This is when you present all your mitigation evidence: – Letters from family, friends, employers – Proof of charitable work or community involvement – Mental health or addiction treatment your doing – Family obligations (kids, elderly parents, etc) – Employment history and what you’ll do after Federal judges can vary from the guidelines based on your “history and characteristics.” Being a first-timer matters most here – not as a legal defense but as proof this is an aberration in your life, not a pattern. We’ve seen judges go 50% below the guidelines for compelling first-timer cases. But you need to present it right!
If your not considered a flight risk (and most first-timers aren’t), judges often allow “voluntary surrender” or “self-surrender.” Instead of being taken into custody right from court, you get 30-60 days to report to your designated prison yourself. This is especialy common for white-collar first-timers and non-violent cases where you’ve been out on bond the whole time. Those weeks are CRUCIAL. Time to get your affairs in order, make arrangements for your family, prepare mentaly and emotionaly. We always push hard for voluntary surrender – it lets you enter federal custody with dignity, not in handcuffs from the courtroom. The Bureau of Prisons also looks at voluntary surrender favorably when deciding where to send you. Self-surrender defendants often get lower security facilities closer to home. That matters alot for visits, programs, and quality of life during your time.
If your facing federal charges as a first-timer, every single decision from this moment forward affects whether you go to prison and for how long. Here’s what’s critical right now: **STOP TALKING** – Don’t talk to investigators, don’t talk to co-defendants, don’t even talk to family about the case details. Everything you say WILL be used against you. We’ve seen first-timers literaly talk themselves into prison trying to “explain” there situation. The feds already know everything – talking only hurts you! **Understand Cooperation** – Federal prosecutors offer huge sentence reductions for cooperation – snitching basicaly. Providing information about others, testifying, wearing a wire. But cooperation is dangerous and complex. You need lawyers who know how to navigate this safely. Alot of first-timers think they have nothing to offer, but sometimes just explaining how a scheme worked is enough. **Start Mitigation NOW** – Get into treatment if you have substance issues. Do community service. Keep working if you can. Show your taking responsibility BEFORE sentencing. Judges want to see your already changing, not promising to change later. **Research Your Judge** – Every federal judge has patterns. Some are harsh on white-collar crime but lenient on drugs. Some hate tax crimes but go easy on fraud. Knowing your judge’s history shapes the entire defense strategy. There’s websites that track federal judges’ sentencing patterns – your lawyer better be checking them!
Look, we’re not gonna sugarcoat this – federal prosecution is absolutely devastating, especialy for first-timers who’ve never been through the system. But there’s a MASSIVE difference between attorneys who understand current federal sentencing law and those working off outdated information. The zero-point offender amendment from 2023? Alot of lawyers still don’t even know it exists! First Step Act calculations? Even fewer understand how to maximize those credits. We see attorneys all the time who don’t know about FFOA until its too late, who don’t understand how to calculate guideline ranges, who don’t know which judges are sympathetic to first-timers. We’ve been defending federal cases for over 40 years. Hundreds of first-time offenders facing everything – fraud, drug conspiracies, tax crimes, RICO, you name it. We know which judges give variances to first-timers, which prosecutors are reasonable, which programs qualify for FSA credits. More importantly, we understand the human side of this nightmare your going through. Your not just worried about prison – your worried about your family falling apart, your career being destroyed, your entire life crumbling. We treat every case like its our own family facing these charges. Because for first-time offenders, this isn’t just about avoiding prison – its about salvaging whatever’s left of your life after the federal government is done with you.
Call Spodek Law Group RIGHT NOW at 212-300-5196
We answer 24/7 because federal arrests don’t follow business hours!
Don’t wait another day hoping this will somehow go away – it won’t! Don’t talk to investigators thinking you can explain yourself out of this – you can’t! Don’t hire some lawyer who doesn’t understand zero-point reductions and FSA credits – that ignorance could cost you YEARS of your life! The decisions you make in the next few weeks will determine not just IF you go to prison, but for how long and under what conditions. Let us fight for every possible reduction, every alternative to incarceration, every single day of credit you deserve. Your family needs you home, not in federal prison!
Disclaimer: This article provides general information about federal sentencing. Every case is different and past results don’t guarantee anything. Federal sentencing law changes frequently. This is attorney advertising.
Very diligent, organized associates; got my case dismissed. Hard working attorneys who can put up with your anxiousness. I was accused of robbing a gemstone dealer. Definitely A law group that lays out all possible options and best alternative routes. Recommended for sure.
- ROBIN, GUN CHARGES ROBIN
NJ CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEYS